There are often multiple
explanations for the observed odds ratios. As example consider
the activity, agreeing to meet offline with an online acquaintance,
and the predictor, has the respondent discussed Internet safety
with a sibling. The odds ratio is 1.248, indicating the odds of
agreeing to meet with someone who was met online are 1.248 times
higher for respondents who have discussed Internet safety with
a sibling. Is this because the siblings are encouraging respondents
to meet with someone who was met online? Or are the discussions
stimulating curiosity and exploration. Or is it that the respondent's
meeting with someone is triggering a safety discussion with a
sibling? Or is there some personality factor (or some environmental
influence) that makes some respondents both more likely to meet
with someone who was met online and more likely to discuss Internet
safety with a sibling. These issues are also observed when there
has been a discussion of Internet safety with peers, and the implications
are currently being explored in more detail.
The resulting model of risk and intervention (See Table 3) will
be used to inform knowledge of the experience of this large sample
of adolescents and will contribute to more intensive projects
to understand mental health issues associated with online victimization
of youth. Additionally, identification of protective factors will
be critical to fostering a safe and productive online experience
for young people.
DISCUSSION
The results of the survey were intended to assess online risks
to adolescents that may be associated with engagement in threatening
behavior or exploitation. This data provides the framework for
the initial design of prevention and safety programs for adolescents
engaged in online activity. Survey results confirm that a significant
number of adolescent girls are engaging in very risky activities
when online and continue potentially problematic offline practices
as a result of these online interactions. The data also confirm
that there is a lapse in preventative intervention to create and
maintain awareness and safety for young people. Moreover, our
research uncovered a preponderance of reported online experiences
which challenged students to confront choices conflicting with
the development of attitudes, values, and social functioning.
In a medium devoid of standards for conduct and codes of ethics,
many young people falter in the quality of their online interactions
with others, demonstrating instead a paucity of respect, responsibility,
honesty, kindness, justice, or tolerance (Willard, 2000).
The Socialization of Youth in Cyberspace
As teens increase the time they spend online they also are increasingly
immersed in an environment that has been shielded from the oversight
and supervision of parents and other significant adults (Cole
et al., 2001). Additionally, teens have a tendency to maintain
secrecy about cyberactivity, contributing to a void of information
about the prevalence of Internet abuse directed toward children.
Ethical, safe and socially conscious online behavior may positively
transform the nature of social interactions among youth and counter
the betrayal, coercion and deception that accompany destructive
behavior.
The survey results highlight the influence of parents and teachers,
whose guidance may assist students in making informed decisions
and allow them to demonstrate an ability to apply online critical
thinking skills and productive social participation. Although
many young people have some awareness of cybersafety as a result
of initial discussions with adults, there appears to be a paucity
of ongoing communication, leaving parents generally unaware of
the online behaviors of their children. This is described by Young
(1998) as a benign neglect of children's Internet activity.
The distancing of parents
from youth as a result of a communication gap and technological
divide highlights the shared responsibility of significant adults
in making sure that children have access to and are safely guided
through the Internet. The role of educators in promoting awareness
of potential harm and the importance of safe and ethical conduct
online is an essential preventative mechanism to counter cyber
misconduct. The Internet presents new teaching challenges which
necessitate educators' involvement in ensuring that children have
safe, rewarding and educational web experiences. Teachers can
help their students assess the value and importance of information
that they find. Since inexperienced Internet users comprise the
majority of victims of cyberstalking (Maxwell, 2001), educators
need to emphasize to students why their privacy is important and
instruct them on how to avoid the traps of disclosing personal
information which could be available to potential offenders. Educators
can also model for students how to check the policies of web sites
to be an informed surfer online and what actions to take when
they become aware of a threatening incident.
The Internet is a powerful environment for enhancing the transfer
of social and emotional skill development. It is replete with
teachable moments when young people are challenged to exhibit
self-control, engage in critical decision-making, and express
feelings while demonstrating respect and tolerance for others.
In fact, as schools increase the amount of access students have
to cyberspace, the application of social skill training to this
setting will become increasingly apparent (Berson, 2000a, p. 159).
Offenders and Victims in Cyberspace: Artifacts of a Culture of
Deception
In the study, many adolescents reported online interactions which
are characteristic of a culture of deception in which students'
primary activities involve the exchange of verbally harassing
or sexually suggestive chat. Young people often perceive that
there is little chance of detection for misconduct online, minimize
the potential harm to others that may result from their actions,
and equate the legality of behavior with the ethics of behavior
(Willard, 2000). For example, there is nothing illegal about lying
about one's age or identity in cyberspace, disseminating sexually
provocative messages regardless of age (i.e., Cybersex), using
profanity online or exploring sexual fantasies (Lanning, 1998).
Due to a perceived lack of consequences, stalking, death threats
and other violent fantasies and behaviors have become more prevalent
among young people online. Computer crimes, such as computer hacking,
also are increasing in frequency, despite their serious offline
legal consequences (Aftab, 2000). Since computer activities appear
to be victimless and faceless crimes the true repercussions may
not be discernible in comparison to the potential benefits gained
by a young person. Students need to be aware of the advent of
more sophisticated technology for tracking down perpetrators of
online offenses in conjunction with legislated legal ramifications
for those who engage in the most potentially harmful behaviors
(Aftab, 2000; Willard, 2000). A recent law enacted prohibits the
transmission of identifying information (names, address, phone
number, Email address) of anyone under age 16 if it is for the
purpose of enticing or soliciting sexual activity with a minor.
Increased vigilance also is noted in the policing of other high
tech computer crimes, such as the distribution of child porn,
even when the possessor of the material is still a youth (Niemiec,
2001).
Our results on girls'
preferred online activity were mirrored in a subsequent survey
which reported that girls spend the majority of their time engaged
in email communication, instant messaging, and chat (AAUW, 2000).
Generally, girls are using the Internet to engage in more relationship
oriented activities. Some respondents noted that online dialogue
is used as a mechanism to empower themselves and find a voice.
In face to face interactions young women may perceive that body
size, facial features, and other superficial characteristics are
judged as more important than personality. Conversely, online
exchanges take place in a context that often is devoid of these
visual cues. In AAUW's study of teenage girls (1999) many girls
admitted repressing their authentic self in order to fit in with
peers. However, in cyberspace, the pressures to fit in and act
a certain way are moderated by the perceived anonymity and false
security of being protected behind the computer screen, often
in the comfort and safety of one's home. Cyberspace provides girls
a context where they can shed their traditional expectations and
explore alternative aspects of themselves.