Regional
Project NE-176 Technical Committee Report - 1998
Dr.
Charles L. Mulchi, Chairman 1998-99
Annual Progress Report:
Characterization and Mechanisms of Plant Responses to Ozone in the
The Technical
Committee for Regional Project NE-176 and the organizations which they
represented are summarized below:
|
Name |
Organization |
|
Patrick Logan Administrative Advisor for
NE-176 |
|
|
Daniel Jones, USDA-CSREES |
|
|
Steve Britz and Mike Robinson USDA-ARS |
Climate Stress Lab |
|
Sagar Krupa |
|
|
William J. Manning |
|
|
Eva Pell and Judy Sinn |
|
|
Fitz Booker, Kent O. Burkey and Joe Miller, USDA-ARS |
Air Quality-Plant Growth
& Development Research Unit |
|
Barbara Zilinskas |
|
|
Boris Chevone |
Virginia Tech, VPI & SU |
|
Charles L. Mulchi |
|
|
Keith R. Davis |
The |
|
Robert Kohut |
Boyce Thompson Institute |
|
Margaret Tuttle McGrath |
Riverhead, NY |
|
A.H. Chappelka |
|
INSTITUTIONAL ACTIVITIES
Barbara Zilinskas -
We have
initiated two new collaborative projects dealing with the response of plants to
ozone. Briefly, the first project, a collaboration with Dr. C. Mulchi, is a characterization of
antioxidants in two wheat cultivars grown in open-top chambers in response to
variations in atmospheric ozone, carbon dioxide and soil moisture. The field work and sampling was done in
Beltsville during the spring-summer of 1996 and 1997. Statistical analyses of yield, stomatal
conductivity for one sampling period, and monodehydroacorabate
reductase and glutathione reductase activity have been completed for all 1997
sampling periods. Ascorbate peroxidase activity
and AsA/DHA and GSH/GSSG ratios will be measured
soon. The second project is a collaboration with Dr. T. Leustek. We found that exposure of plants to ozone
induces a rapid and large increase in 5'-adenylsulfate (APS) reductase
activity. The APS reductase activity
correlated directly with the oxidized state of the glutathione pool and
inversely with the level of cysteine and total
glutathione. Our work suggests that
redox regulation of APS reductase may provide a mechanism for rapid response to
oxidative stress.
Boris Chevone - Virginia Tech (VPI):
Two clones of
white clover, (cv. Regal), one that
is ozone sensitive (NC-S) and one that is ozone tolerant (NC-R) have been
utilized to investigate mechanisms involved in oxidative tolerance. During the past several years, clover has
been grown in pots at the
Two clones of
clover also have been utilized examining biochemical mechanisms of oxidative
tolerance. We have identified 2-4 low
molecular mass proteins that are induced by ozone to a greater extent in NC-R
than in NC-S. Amino acid analysis of the
most abundant, gel-purified protein indicated that the N-terminal amino acid
was blocked and a sequence could not be obtained. In-gel protease digestion of this protein
produced four major fragments; however, the peptide yield was insufficient for
amino acid sequencing. Because of the
difficulty in regenerating and transforming clover, research of ozone tolerance
mechanisms has shifted to tobacco cultivars Bel-W3 and NC88 (ozone sensitive), Bel-B (ozone tolerant) and Xanthi
(moderately ozone tolerant). We have
examined HMGR promoter:GUS
fusions transformed into Xanthi and have observed
promoter activation in response to 200 ppb ozone exposure for 3 hr. GUS activity was localized around necrotic
lesions on the leaf tissue.
Mike Robinson and Steve Britz - USDA-ARS-BARC:
A study was
continued to further determine whether there was a positive correlation between
the ability of soybean plants to remain productive during prolonged exposure to
moderate ozone levels and the level of ascorbate in the leaflets of those
plants. In studies conducted in the
summer of 1997 at Beltsville, an O3-tolerant soybean cultivar (cv Essex)
and an O3-sensitive
cultivar (cv Forrest) were grown, concurrently, from the seedling stage through
bean harvest. Plants were grown in soil
plots within open‑top chambers aerated continuously either with
carbon-filtered air (CF) (average daily O3 was »30 ppb), or with non‑filtered
air supplemented with O3 (NF+ O3) (average O3 was »60 ppb). During the same period, both cultivars were
grown in ambient air (AMB) in plots just adjacent to the chambers. Elevated O3 exposure decreased
both the biomass per plant and the bean yield per plant of cv
Forrest by approximately 20%, while neither biomass yield per plant nor the
bean yield per plant of cv Essex appeared to be affected by O3. Upper canopy leaflets of plants of both
cultivars were sampled at the vegetative, flowering and pod‑fill
stages. On designated days of each
growth stage, leaf disk samples were excised from mature leaflets at »0830, »1130, and »1430 hrs. Ascorbate (ASC) and dehydroascorbate (DHA)
were measured enzymatically in leaflet disk extracts. At each each growth
stage, CF, NF+O3, and AMB cv Essex leaflets were able to maintain a
high steady‑state ASC level and ASC mole fraction (»0.8‑0.9), especially during the mid-day
to afternoon period. In comparison with cv
Meg McGrath -
Plant response
to ambient ozone on
Charles Mulchi, Moon Kim and Tanya Chernikova -
Modeling Gaseous Exchange in Soybean
Using leaf
photosynthesis, stomatal conductance, transpiration rates, ambient and elevated
chamber O3 and CO2 concentrations obtained during field
studies with soybeans conducted during the summers of 1994 through 1997, gas
exchange responses were modeled under well-watered and moisture-deficient
conditions. The results were combined
over cultivars. Under high moisture, Pn rates were increased linearly in response to CO2
and decreased linearly in response to elevated O3 during pre- and
post-flowering. Under low moisture, Pn responses behaved similarly to high moisture conditions
during pre-flowering but were strongly curvilinear downward under
post-flowering with increased O3 concentration at all CO2
concentrations. Stomatal conductance
showed slight curvilinear downward patterns with increases in both CO2
and O3 during pre-flowering under high moisture, but showed linear
increases in response to both gases during post-flowering. Under low moisture, rs
values were curvilinear downward in response to elevated O3 at all
CO2 levels and curvilinear upward under elevated CO2
during pre-flowering but were typically reversed under post-flowering. O3 uptake or flux into the leaves
increased linearly with O3 concentrations during pre-flowering at
all CO2 concentrations and were only slightly decreased in response
to elevated CO2. However,
during post-flowering, O3 uptake rates were curvilinear with
increased O3 under low O3 and high moisture but downward
under high O3 and low moisture, clearly illustrating the effects of
reduced stomatal conductance during post-flowering under low moisture. Transpiration (E) values were largely
decreased in response to elevated CO2 under low O3 during
both pre- and post-flowering but were unaffected by CO2 under
elevated O3. However, under
low moisture, E values were curvilinear downward in response to increased CO2
at all O3 levels during pre-flowering but strongly curvilinear
downward in response to O3 at all CO2 levels. WUE values were increased in response to CO2
at all O3 levels with the sharpest increases occurring during low
moisture and moderate to low O3 conditions. Under high moisture, WUE values were largely unaffected by
O3 concentration but were slightly increased by O3 under
low CO2 and low moisture during post-flowering, suggesting O3
has a role in water economy during drought.
Leaf Fluorescence
The primary
objective was to characterize fluorescence responses as a noninvasive detection
method for crop species subjected to elevated atmospheric CO2 and O3
under two soil moisture regimes. A
laboratory-based fluorescence imaging system (FIS) was developed to capture and
process images of plant leaves at the blue (F450), green (F550), red (F680),
and far-red (F740) regions of the spectrum.
Full surface imaging was superior to point source measurements in
assessing fluorescence characteristics of plant leaves.
Field
experiments were conducted at the
The results from
this investigation demonstrated that chronic exposures of soybean leaves to air
quality treatments varying in O3 and CO2 concentrations
produced significant
alterations in steady-state fluorescence values at F450, F550,
F680 and F740 even in the absence of visual symptoms or significant changes in
gas exchange parameters. Likewise, soil
moisture treatments caused significant changes in fluorescence responses
throughout the spectrum. The FIS
detected the effects of elevated O3, partial compensation of
elevated O3 effects in response to elevated CO2, and
positive physiological effects of elevated CO2 on plants under WW
and RM regimes. Cultivar sensitivities
in response to air quality and soil moisture treatments were also
differentiated with the FIS. Among the
more significant findings in this investigation was that blue-green
fluorescence emission from leaves was highly responsive to oxidative O3
stress at levels that were sub-lethal.
On the basis of
findings from this research in conjunction with advances in detector and laser
technologies, a laser-induced fluorescence imaging system (LIFIS) capable of in situ canopy level measurements was
proposed and is currently being developed jointly by NASA/GSFC and USDA/BARC.
Future research
considerations are addressed for the use of steady-state fluorescence as a
viable early remote detection method for assessing plant stress factors.
Joe Miller, Al Heagle, Fitz Booker and Kent Burkey -
USDA-ARS - Raleigh, NC:
Field
experiments to determine combined effects of elevated CO2 and O3
were performed with two wheat cultivars — one O3-sensitive (NK-9904)
and one O3-resistant (NK-9835).
Plants were grown in open-top chambers and treated with all combinations
of three CO2 and three O3 concentrations in a replicated
design. Carbon dioxide treatments [374
(ambient), 541, and 707 ppm] were given for 24 hr/day to obtain designated
concentrations. Ozone treatments were
charcoal-filtered air (CF; 27 ppb), nonfiltered air (NF; 44 ppb), and NF with O3
added in proportion to ambient O3 (
A field
experiment showed that ambient concentrations of tropospheric O3 in
Ascorbic acid
present in leaf apoplastic fluid may limit ozone injury by participating in
reactions that detoxify ozone prior to plasma membrane damage. To assess the relationship between apoplast
ascorbate and ozone stress, seven genotypes of snap bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) known to differ in ozone sensitivity were
compared in an open top chamber study.
Plants were then subjected to either CF conditions (29 nmol mol-1 ozone)
or elevated ozone (CF+O3, 67nmol mol-1 ozone). Following an eight-day treatment period,
vacuum infiltration methods were employed to separate leaf ascorbic acid into
apoplast and cytoplasm fractions. Under
CF conditions, afternoon apoplast ascorbic acid levels in the fourth trifoliate
leaf were in the range of 100 to 150 nmol g-1FW for all genotypes,
representing 3 to 5% of total leaf ascorbate.
In general, apoplast ascorbate increased in ozone-treated plants
relative to CF controls with ozone-sensitive genotypes exhibiting larger
increases than tolerant genotypes. The
results suggest that ascorbic acid in the cell wall plays a role in plant
response to ozone stress.
Keith Davis, Mulpuri V.
Rao and Jennifer Riehl Koch -
The long-term
goal of this research is to identify molecular mechanisms controlling the
effects of ozone on plants. These
studies will utilize a combination of molecular and genetic approaches to
examine the effects of ozone on the model plant systems, Arabidopsis and hybrid
poplar. Our studies, along with others,
have clearly shown that these model plants offer significant advantages for
applying genetic and molecular genetic approaches to the study of ozone-induced
responses to plants. The long-term goal
of this project is to identify the regulatory mechanisms underlying
ozone-induced responses in plants, particularly with respect to the signal
transduction pathways that modulate ozone-induced effects. We will investigate specific mechanisms that
control ozone effects on plant gene expression and how ozone interacts with
signal transduction pathways activated by other biotic and abiotic
stresses. These studies will provide
detailed information concerning the mechanisms that control the expression of
genes that play an important role in ozone-induced responses in plants and the
establishment of defense mechanisms against ozone exposure. This will provide a better understanding of
the cellular signaling processes involved in the induction of protective
antioxidant molecules that provide tolerance against highly reactive and
damaging oxygen radicals. Thus, these
studies will have a direct bearing on plants’ responses to other oxidative
stresses such as drought, UV-irradiation and exposure to heavy metals. Our studies will provide a sound basis for
understanding the underlying mechanisms of ozone damage in plants and provide
the basic knowledge necessary to rationally develop methods for the
establishment of plants resistant to oxidative stress.
Specific Aims
Specific aims
include 1) molecular genetic analyses of ozone-sensitive Arabidopsis ecotypes,
including the cloning of the major sensitivity loci in the highly sensitive
ecotype, Cvi; 2) the isolation and characterization
of mutant Arabidopsis plants altered in their response to ozone; 3) detailed
analyses of the ozone response of existing Arabidopsis mutants altered in the
salicylic acid, jasmonic acid and ethylene response pathways; 4) identification
and characterization of novel ozone-induced defense genes in hybrid poplar; 5)
defining the roles of SA, JA and ethylene in modulating ozone-induced gene
expression in hybrid poplar; and 6) characterization of the mechanisms of
transcriptional control of defense genes induced by oxidative stress in hybrid
poplar.
Key Results
The high level
of ozone-sensitivity in the Arabidopsis ecotype Cvi
is due to the induction of hypersensitive cell death. Sensitivity is conferred by two interacting
loci; the major sensitivity locus has been mapped to the bottom of chromosome
2. Lesion formation is controlled by the
interaction of at least two signaling pathways that are dependent on SA and JA
respectively. Preliminary evidence
indicates that ethylene also modulates the response by interacting with the SA
and JA pathways.
The differential
ozone sensitivity of two hybrid poplar clones has been found to be due to
differences in these clones to respond to signal molecules such as JA and
SA. The ozone-tolerant clone (245)
exhibits high levels of defense gene expression in response to ozone and
exogenous treatments with either SA or JA.
The ozone-sensitive clone (388) has greatly attenuated defense gene
induction in response to ozone, SA or JA treatments.
William J. Manning -
Richard Flagler
and W.J. Manning began an experiment in the
Sagar Krupa -
During late July
1998, unifacial, interveinal
chlorsis was observed on some 12% of the seedlings at
one study site. By September, the
chlorosis had become more severe (necrosis) on some 70% of the plants at that site. Site specific ambient SO2 levels
were relatively low (maximum 5-minute concentration of 52.8 ppb). Similar data were unavailable for all, but
one other site. Therefore, foliar total
S and SO42- concentrations were analyzed in September at
four of the five study sites. Previously soil SO42--S at
these sites had been analyzed. There
were spatial variabilities among these
parameters. Based on the overall
examination of these data, it is concluded that the observed visible injury
symptoms were due to chronic SO2 exposures, exacerbated by the
presence of ozone (O3).
Independent of this literature-based speculation, visible foliar injury
responses of
A.H. Chappelka -
During 1998, a
study was completed and analyzed on the response of “wild plants” with varying
ozone concentrations. Species numbers, percent cover and the rate of blackberry:broomsedge litter
decomposition were reduced with increasing ozone concentrations. Blackberry flowering and fruit production was
affected by ozone exposure the previous year.
Blackberry grown in elevated ozone exhibited increased flower production
and more aborted fruits than those grown in charcoal filtered air. A study is being designed to test the effects
of ozone on the competitive relationships among native vegetation. Exposure-response relationships between
ambient ozone concentrations and visible injury on mature black cherry in two
National Parks in the eastern
Bob Kohut, John Laurence, Robert Eckert and Thomas
Lee -
Boyce Thompson Institute:
Identification of Bioindicators for Ozone and
Assessment of Impacts at
Exposures of
native species of plants in open-top chambers at Acadia National Park indicated
that black cherry, quaking aspen, white ash, jack pine, big-leaf aster, and
spreading dogbane were sensitive to ambient levels of ozone, with red maple,
pin, cherry, mountain ash, mountain holly, and flat-topped aster possibly
sensitive. Species injured at levels of
ozone 50% greater than ambient were gray birch, small sundrops,
and bunchberry. Species uninjured at
twice the ambient level of ozone were paper birch, eastern white pine, pitch
pine, red spruce, northen white cedar, northern red
oak, Canada bluejoint
grass, wild radish, and Canada mayflower.
Clonal lines of eastern white pine
derived from trees in the park considered to be responsive to ambient ozone
were not affected by levels of ozone up to three times ambient concentrations
in two consecutive years of exposure.
There was no relationship between the type or degree of marking and the
treatment level of ozone. The lack of
response to three times ambient levels of ozone raises doubt that ozone is
responsible for the foliar markings observed in the field.
Field surveys
were conducted from 1992 through 1997 to assess the incidence and severity of
foliar ozone injury on plants in the park.
The primary species examined were big-leaf aster and spreading dogbane
since these were the most sensitive species and it was possible to assess many
individual plants in a limited period of time.
Surveys were conducted on 30 permanent plots with 90 individuals of a
species assessed on each plot.
Ozone or
ozone-like symptoms were found each year, but their occurrence and intensity
were highly variable. Although ambient
levels of ozone were high in several years, when precipitation was low the
plants expressed little if any injury.
When
Predicting the Regional Impact of Ozone on the
Growth of Eastern Hardwood Forests Using Linked TREGRO and ZELIG Models
We simulated the
long-term effects of ozone on eastern hardwood forests in the
Eva Pell -
Experiments were
conducted to determine the molecular biology of ozone (O3)-induced
foliar senescence. Arabidopsis plants treated with 0.15 ppm O3 for 6-h d-1
for 14 d and expression of 13 senescence associated genes (SAG) were determined
every 2-d throughout exposure. Eight of
the SAG genes were expressed earlier in O3-treated than nontreated plants.
Transgenic Arabidopsis lines
that have either the SAG12 or the SAG13 promoter fused to the GUS reporter
gene developed in the laboratory of R. Amasino (
PUBLICATIONS
Ali, A.A. 1998.
Ecological and Biological Studies on the Effect of Pollutants on Some
Plants and Their Associated Microorganisms.
Ph.D. Dissertation,
Ali, A.A.,
C.L. Mulchi, K.R. Islam, Y.A. Elzawahry and R.L. Abdelfalk. 1998. Carbon and
Ali, A.A.,
C.L. Mulchi, K.R. Islam, Y.A. Elzawahry and R.L. Abdelfattah. 1998. Soil
Respiration Responses to Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide, Ozone and Soil Moisture
Regimes in Soybean/Wheat Agroecosystems.
Agron. Abstracts. ASA Ann. Meetings.
Andrews, T. 1998.
Rapid Screening of Soybean Germplasm for Tolerance to Ozone Stress by
Examining Growth Characteristics and Antioxidant Enzymes. MS Thesis,
Andrews,
T., C.L. Mulchi, and T. Solomon. 1998. Rapid Screeing of
Soybean Germplasm for Tolerance to Oxidative Stress. Northeastern Branch ASA
Abstracts.
Barbo,
D.N., A.H. Chappelka, G.L. Somers, M.S. Miller-Goodman and K. Stolte. 1998.
Diversity of an early successional plant community as influenced by
ozone. New Phytol.
138:653-662.
Booker,
F.L. and J.E. Miller. 1998. Phenylpropanoid metabolism and phenolic
composition of soybean [Glycine Max (L.) Merr.] leaves following exposure to ozone. J.
Experimental Botany 49:1119-1202.
Brendley, B. and Pell,
E.J. 1998. Ozone-induced changes in biosynthesis of
Rubisco and associated compensation to stress in foliage of hybrid poplar. Tree
Physiology 18:81-90.
Chappelka,
A.H. and L.J. Samuelson. 1998. Ambient ozone effects on forest trees of the
eastern
Chappelka,
A., J. Skelly, G. Somers, J. Renfro and E. Hildebrand. 199_. Mature black cherry used as a bioindicator of
ozone injury. Water, Air and Soil Pollut.
(In press).
Chappelka,
A., G. Somers and J. Renfro. 199_. Ozone effects
to forest trees in
Chernikova, T. 1998. Ozone Effects on Growth, Physiological
Characteristics and Antioxidant Enzymes in Soybean Cultivars Exposed to Ambient
and Elevated CO2. Ph.D. Dissertation,
Chernikova,
T., C.L. Mulchi, L. Douglass, E.H. Lee, and R. Rowland. 1998.
Gas-Exchange Responses of Soybean Plants to Carbon Dioxide, Ozone and
Moisture Deficit. Agron. Abstracts. ASA Ann. Meetings.
Chevone,
B., W. Manning, A. Varbanov, and S. Krupa. 1988.
Relating ambient ozone concentrations to adverse biomass responses of
white clover: A case study. Environ. Pollut. 103:103-108.
Heagle,
A.S., J.E. Miller, and F.L. Booker. 1998. Influence of ozone stress on soybean response
to carbon dioxide enrichment. I. Foliar
properties. Crop Science 38:113-121.
Heagle,
A.S., J.E. Miller, and W.A. Pursley. 1998. Influence of ozone stress on soybean response
to carbon dioxide enrichment. III. Yield
and seed quality. Crop Science 38:128-134.
Hummel,
R.L., R.L. Brandenburg, A.S. Heagle and C. Arellano. 1998.
Effects of ozone on reproduction of twospotted
spider mite (Acari: Tetranychidae) on white clover. Environ.
Entomol.
27:388-394.
Kim, M. 1999. Ambient Effects of Elevated
Tropospheric Ozone, Elevated Carbon-Dioxide and Soil Moisture Deficit on
Soybeans Using Fluorescence Imaging.
Ph.D. Dissertation,
Kim, J.S.,
A.H. Chappelka and M.S. Miller-Goodman.
1998. Decomposition of blackberry
and broomsedge bluestem as influenced by ozone.
J. Environ. Qual.
27:953-960.
Kim, M.S.,
C.L. Mulchi, C.S.T. Daughtry, E.W. Chappelle, E.H.
Lee, and R. Rowland. 1998. Nondestructive Detection of Increased
Tropospheric Ozone and Carbon Dioxide Effects on Crops with a
Fluorescence Imagine System. Agron. Abstracts. ASA Ann. Meetings.
Koch, J.R., Scherzer, A.J.,
Eshita, S.M. and
Krupa,
S.V., Nosal, M. and Legge, A.H. 1998. A numerical analysis of the combined open-top
chamber data from the
Krupa, S.V., Tonneijck, A.E.G. and Manning, W.J. 1998.
Ozone. In Recognition of Air Pollution Injury to Vegetation: A Pictorial
Atlas, ed. R.B. Flagler. Air and Waste Management Association,
Leblanc,
E. 1998.
Physiological and Spectral Characterization of the Effects of
Atmospheric CO2 and Tropospheric O3 on Wheat and Soybean Cultivars
Grown Under Well-Watered and Restricted Moisture Conditions. Ph.D. Dissertation,
Leblanc,
E., C.L. Mulchi, and C.S.T. Daughtry. 1998. Soil Moisture Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide,
Ozone Effects on Wheat and Soybeans. Agron. Abstracts. ASA Ann. Meetings,
Miller, J.D., Arteca, R.N.,
and Pell, E.J. 1998. Ozone-induced changes in senescence- and
photosynthesis-associated gene expression.
Plant Physiology Abstract Supplement p. 109.
Miller,
J.E., A.S. Heagle, and W.A. Pursley. 1998. Influence of ozone stress on soybean response
to carbon dioxide enrichment. II. Biomass and
development. Crop Science 38:122-128.
Rao, M.
and
Reid,
C.D., and E.L. Fiscus. 1998. Effects of elevated [CO2] and/or
ozone on limitations to CO2 assimilation in soybean (Glycine
max). J. Experimental Botany 49:885-895.
Robinson, J.M., Britz, S.J.,
Rowland, R.A. and Stracke, W.F. 1998.
Influence of chronic ozonation on ascorbate accumulation and the
ascorbate/dehydroascorbate redox status in leaflets of field grown soybean
cultivars which demonstrate tolerance or sensitivity to ozone, pp 439-442. In:
L.J. De Kok and
Robinson, J.M. and Britz,
S.J. 1999. Leaflet ascorbate to dehydroascorbate redox
status in field grown ozone tolerant and ozone sensitive cultivars during the
vegetative and reproductive growth stages.
Plant Physiol. Supplement, Volume 120(3): Abstract #445.
Shafer,
S.R., U. Blum, S.J. Horton, and D.L. Hesterberg. 1998.
Biomass of tomato seedlings exposed to an allelopathic phenolic acid and
enriched atmospheric carbon dioxide. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution
106:123-136.
Somers,
G.L., A.H. Chappelka, P. Rosseau and J.R. Renfro. 1998. Empirical
evidence of growth decline related to visible ozone injury. For. Ecol. and Manag. 104:129-137.
Tang, Y. 1998. Response of leaf protein to ozone in two
white clover clones. M.S. Thesis.
Torsethaugen, G., Romano,
Vahala, J., Schlagnhaufer,
C.D. and Pell, E.J. 1998. Induction of an ACC synthase
cDNA by ozone in light-grown Arabidopsis
thaliana leaves. Physiologia Plantarum 103:45-50.