SAES-422

Multistate Research Activity

Accomplishments Report

Project/Activity Number: NE-176

Project Title: Characterization and Mechanisms of Plant Responses to Ozone (O3) in the Northeastern US

Period Covered: October 1, 1995September 30, 2002

Date of This Report: August 3, 2005

Annual Meeting Dates:  April 17, 1996;  January 5-6, 1997;  May 18-19, 1998;  May 18-19, 1999;  January 8-9, 2000;  June 2-3, 2001; May 9-10, 2002

Participants: Chris Andersen (EPA, OR), Fitzgerald Booker (USDA, NC), Steve Britz (BARC, USDA), Kent Burkey (USDA, NC), Art Chappelka (AL), Boris Chevone (VA), David Grantz (CA), Allen Heagle (USDA, NC), Robert Kohut (NY), Sagar Krupa (MN), Ed Lee (BARC, USDA), William Manning (MA, Margaret McGrath (NY), Joseph Miller (USDA, NC), Charles Mulchi (MD), Howard Neufeld (NC), Eva Pell (PA), Mike Robinson (BARC, MD), John Skelly (PA), Barbara Zilinskas (NJ)

Art Chappelka              Auburn University

Boris Chevone              Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University

David Grantz                University of California – Riverside

Robert Kohut               Boyce Thompson Institute

Sagar Krupa                 University of Minnesota

William Manning           University of Massachusetts

Margaret McGrath       Cornell University

Charles Mulchi             University of Maryland

Howard Neufeld           Appalachian State University

Eva Pell                        The Pennsylvania State University

John Skelly                   The Pennsylvania State University

Barbara Zilinskas          Rutgers University

 

Chris Andersen             U.S. EPA, Corvallis, OR

 

Fitzgerald Booker         USDA-ARS Air Quality Research Unit, Raleigh, NC

Kent Burkey

Allen Heagle

Joseph Miller

 

Steve Britz                    USDA-ARS Climate Stress Unit, Beltsville, MD

Ed Lee

Mike Robinson

 

Jack Barnes                  CSREES Representative, Beltsville, MD

Robin Huettel

Daniel Jones

 

Pat Logan                     University of Rhode Island

Robert Seem                Cornell University

Summary of minutes of annual meetings1995    1996-2002

Publications 1995-2002

Accomplishments and Impacts:

Over 200 peer-reviewed publications, book chapters, and theses (21) were produced during this project.  These publications include 18 papers co-authored by project participants from different locations.  One paper was entirely co-authored by members of the project and highlighted the objectives and accomplishments of NE-176 (Krupa, S, MT McGrath, C Andersen, FL Booker, KO Burkey, AH Chappelka, BI Chevone, EJ Pell, BA Zilinskas. 2001.  Ambient ozone and plant health.  Plant Disease 85:4-12).  Also, five members of the project served as peer-reviewers for the Draft US EPA Air Quality Criteria Document for Ozone and Related Photochemical Oxidants. 

Significant accomplishments were made regarding ozone-elicited molecular and physiological responses.  Research indicated that ozone inhibits carbon fixation and translocation by plants and induces numerous plant defense responses against oxidative stress.  Landmark research findings by Eva Pell’s laboratory showed that ozone inhibits a primary enzyme (Rubisco) involved in photosynthesis and stimulates genes involved in plant senescence, which reduces growth and yield of sensitive plants.  Ozone may also lower the rate of sugar export from leaves, which further limits growth and yield.  Several laboratories in our group made important discoveries regarding the biochemical basis for differences in ozone sensitivity among plant species and cultivars based on the level of ascorbic acid found in plant leaves.  This research has paved the way for a better understanding of the molecular and biochemical pathways involved in ozone toxicity and provided the underpinnings for genetic modifications aimed at increasing plant resistance to ambient ozone and other oxidative stressors in the environment.      

Research on interactions between tropospheric ozone and other environmental factors showed that elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide can suppress ozone damage in crops such as soybean, bean, cotton, and wheat.  A major finding was that crop growth and yield stimulation by elevated carbon dioxide could be attributed in part to decreased damage from ambient ozone due to reductions in ozone uptake at elevated carbon dioxide concentrations.  Significant variability in physiological, growth, and yield responses was found among crops and cultivars due to differing sensitivities to ozone injury.  At present it is unclear how future changes in atmospheric trace gas concentrations will affect crop production and forest health, although increasing ambient ozone concentrations will likely detract from the potentially beneficial effects of elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide on plant growth.            

Advances were made in identifying and documenting ambient ozone injury to crop and native plants.  A multi-site project conducted by members of this project showed that ambient ozone caused visible injury and reduced growth of bioindicator plants (Heagle et al. 1996. Responses of a white clover indicator system to tropospheric ozone at eight locations in the United States. Water, Air and Soil Pollution 85: 1373-1378).  Computer models were developed to capture cause (ozone) and effect (crop response) relationships under ambient conditions.  These models are also capable of segregating the individual contributions of various climatic factors to crop growth and productivity.  Surveys and models indicate that injury to plants from ambient ozone is pervasive in most regions of the U.S. and other industrialized countries worldwide.

 

Overall, project accomplishments made significant strides toward achieving the project goals.  The large number of publications that emanated from research conducted by members of this project was a major accomplishment.  Advances were made at all levels of research interest, from the molecular to the ecosystem level in both agricultural and forest systems.  Findings at basic biological levels contributed to our understanding of ambient ozone effects on whole-plants, communities, and ecosystems.  The converse was also true.  Thus, progress was made toward the goal of integrating and understanding ozone effects at multiple levels of biological organization.  Effects of biotic and abiotic factors that determine plant responses to ozone were also investigated.  The research was conducted at various laboratories affiliated with the project in both coordinated multi-site experiments and as informal associations among researchers interested in similar questions.  The project served to facilitate research by fostering communication and collaboration among participants.  The outreach objective was met by publication of general-interest and review papers, the open forum of annual meetings at which interested guests were invited to attend and participate, and by participation in peer-review panels for US EPA Ozone Criteria Document preparation.  We consider the project to be an outstanding success and plan to promote its continuation.